Save for the slightly different ending, I have never seen a comic book adaptation as accurate as
Watchmen--- at least visually speaking. Every single frame seemed to be lifted from the graphic novel. In terms of being loyal to the source material, most fans would be pleased. Yet, it just doesn't seem the same. Whereas the graphic novel was a multilayered masterpiece, the movie adaptation seems like a cheap and hollow reproduction, devoid of its original essence. Yes, the film is a spectacle, but the whole story seemed to have lost its soul. I hate to sound like the typical fanboy. Obviously, the original literature will always be better than the adaptation. A lot of scenes were cut out--- that's to be expected; it's impossible to fit everything in just 2-3 hours. But as a consequence, the whole adaptation seemed very incomplete. Some sequences in the graphic novel that aren't really part of the main narrative proved to be essential, and all these were not included in the movie. The excerpts from Hollis Mason's book, the newspaper clippings, the medical files--- pages that were inserted in between chapters expounded the whole mythology. Those pages made the readers know the characters more. Even
The Tales of the Black Freighter story within a story enhanced the whole experience. Individual aspects from the comic book made it great. Apparently, when even the seemingly insignificant parts are taken out, it creates a less than fulfilling experience.
Now I'm sounding like a fanboy who keeps on complaining about movie adaptations of their favorite books. I can't help it! It's difficult to really enjoy the movie when you've read the original graphic novel. I just can't help but compare it to the source material. It's not a bad movie, it's just not exceptional either. Maybe Alan Moore was right when he said that it was impossible to make a movie adaptation of Watchmen. But what about those people who have never read the graphic novel--- would they enjoy watching this movie? I guess all that eye candy would impress some folks, and some of the themes and dialogues are indeed thought provoking--- that could impress those looking for some depth. But judging from the reaction of the other people inside the movie theater, the film makers failed to make the movie mainstream enough. Some would get lost in the narrative. Some would find the whole alternate America too campy. Those people expecting another
300 will be really disappointed.
This movie won't please most Watchmen fans. I don't think it will turn the average moviegoer into a Watchmen fan either.